Research on Women's Mental Load, Guilt and Pressure

HOME  →  RESEARCH

46 studies · 5 topics

What women carry, and what the research says about it

Guilt, mental load, the pressure to get it right, and putting your own needs aside. These are plain-language summaries of 46 studies and reports, each with a link to the original paper. Start with three numbers, or jump straight to a topic.

Newsletter

Get new research in your inbox

Sign up to hear when new studies are added and what I am writing about.

2x

Women felt guilty in 18% of their leisure moments, twice the rate of men (9%).

43%

of women surveyed around the world said they want to leave their current employer.

0 of 32

couples in one interview study reported an even split of both physical and cognitive household labor.

Browse by topic

Where guilt shows up in everyday life, who feels it most, and what it costs.

The pressure to be a perfect parent, and what happens when real life falls short.

Who does the thinking, planning and unpaid work that keeps a household running.

Putting your own needs aside, overthinking, and the emotional demands of work.

Body dissatisfaction in midlife and how it connects to mood and eating.

How to read these

Check who was studied

Many studies focus on women, and several sample one country or a small group. Each card lists who took part. Two items are industry or think tank reports and are labeled as not peer reviewed.

11 studies

Guilt and shame

Where guilt shows up in everyday life, who feels it most, and what it costs.

Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin · 2026

Leisure Guilt (Koo et al., 2026)

Did you know? Women felt guilty during 18% of their leisure moments, twice the rate of men (9%). Guilt was also much more common when people relaxed alone (19%) than with others (9%).

Key findings

  • People felt guilty in about 1 in 7 leisure moments (14%). In a separate survey of 1,000 U.S. adults, 64% said they had felt guilty about leisure at some point.
  • Guilt was more common in women (18% of leisure moments vs. 9% for men), younger adults (17% vs. 10% for older adults), and people with lower income (18% vs. 12%) or lower social status (16% vs. 11%). White and non-White participants did not differ.
  • It was more common when people were alone (19%) than with others (9%).
  • People prone to this guilt felt it much more often (24% of leisure moments vs. 4% for the least prone) and enjoyed leisure less, felt less happy, and had more negative emotions during it.
  • They also reported lower well-being overall, with more stress and anxiety.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2026; a nationally representative prevalence question was fielded February to March 2025, other collection dates not stated. Four studies on leisure guilt: feeling guilty or uneasy about relaxing instead of being productive. The researchers built a short questionnaire to measure it, then tracked it in daily life. Participants were adults recruited online through Prolific: 298, 455 and 301 people in the three questionnaire studies, and 305 in a week-long smartphone study (average age 35, about half women) with 11,447 check-ins.

Read the original paper →

Sex Roles · 2005

Individual Differences in Experiences of and Responses to Guilt and Shame: Lenses of Gender and Gender Role

Did you know? Women scored higher than men on being prone to both guilt and shame, yet men reported more guilt as a lasting trait. After feeling guilty, women with a strongly gendered self-image favored talking it through, while men favored taking action.

Key findings

  • Women reported being more prone to both guilt and shame than men (guilt-proneness 61.1 vs. 55.0 and shame-proneness 40.7 vs. 36.5 on a standard scale). Men reported more guilt as a lasting trait (62.0 vs. 55.6).
  • People with more traditionally feminine gender roles were more prone to guilt and shame.
  • After guilt, women with a strongly gendered self-image favored talking it through, while men favored taking action.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2005; data collection year not stated. A survey of 104 college students (53 women and 51 men, 85% White), about how prone they are to guilt and shame and how they respond to those feelings.

Read the original paper →

Journal of Personality · 2017

The Interpersonal Adaptiveness of Dispositional Guilt and Shame: A Meta-Analysis

Did you know? Guilt-prone people were slightly kinder and more caring toward others, but shame-prone people got no such benefit. Guilt may do more good than we assume, while shame does not.

Key findings

  • Guilt-prone people were slightly more caring toward others (average correlation of .13).
  • Shame-proneness showed no clear benefit, with a tiny negative link (-.05) that was not clearly different from zero.
  • Results varied depending on how each study measured guilt and shame.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2017; combines earlier studies. A meta-analysis, which combines the results of many earlier studies, on whether people prone to guilt or shame treat others better: 63 studies on guilt and 47 on shame.

Read the original paper →

Appetite · 2009

Guilty or not? Feelings of guilt about food among college women

Did you know? Two in three college women (66%) felt guilty about food at least once in a single week. The odds of guilt were about 22 times higher after dinner than at breakfast.

Key findings

  • Two in three women (66%) felt guilty about food at least once during the week, and guilt came up at about 1 in 9 eating moments (12%). Nearly all of it was mild: 86% of guilty moments were “a little guilty” and only 3% were “very guilty.”
  • The guilt came mostly after afternoon snacks and evening eating, and most often involved candy and ice cream. The odds of guilt were about 22 times higher after dinner than at breakfast, and about 4 times higher when eating at a friend’s house than at home. Candy and ice cream triggered guilt 25% of the time, and crisps and nuts 30%.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2009; data collection year not stated. 55 Dutch college women (average age 20.7) kept a food diary for one week. Only women were studied, so there is no comparison with men.

Read the original paper →

Journal of Vocational Behavior · 2019

Work-Family Guilt as a Straightjacket (Aarntzen et al., 2019)

Did you know? On days when working mothers felt more guilty, they got about 24 fewer minutes of their own leisure time for each 1-point rise in guilt. In interviews, 13 of 14 mothers felt guilty toward their children, compared with 7 of 14 fathers.

Key findings

  • In interviews, 13 of 14 mothers and 7 of 14 fathers felt guilty toward their children.
  • Guilt about work came up for 5 of 14 mothers and 1 of 14 fathers. Guilt toward their partner came up for 6 of 14 mothers and 4 of 14 fathers.
  • 3 of 14 mothers said they felt like a bad parent. No fathers did. Mothers described making up for it, while fathers more often justified their choices.
  • On days with more guilt, mothers took about 24 fewer minutes of their own leisure per 1-point rise in guilt on a 5-point scale, thought more about cutting their work hours, and planned more time with their kids.
  • Those same days, mothers were less attentive as parents and reported lower happiness (down 0.27 points) and lower work-family satisfaction (down 0.52 points) per 1-point rise in guilt. Some of the dip carried into the next day.
  • The authors argue that this guilt pushes mothers toward traditional gender roles.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2019; data collection year not stated. Interviews with 28 working parents (14 Dutch couples with a child age 6 or under; 71% were married; mothers contracted to work 27 hours a week vs. 39 for fathers), plus a daily questionnaire completed for 8 days by 123 mothers (ages 25 to 50, average 39).

Read the original paper →

Community, Work & Family · 2021

How Individual Gender Role Beliefs, Organizational Gender Norms, and National Gender Norms Predict Parents' Work-Family Guilt in Europe (Aarntzen et al., 2021)

Did you know? Fathers with traditional gender beliefs who worked long hours felt less guilty, but mothers working long hours felt especially guilty when their workplace gave little support to fathers as parents.

Key findings

  • Among parents working more than a full-time week, fathers with traditional beliefs about gender roles felt less guilty.
  • Mothers working long hours felt especially guilty when their workplace gave little support to fathers’ role as parents.
  • National gender norms made no difference to the gender gap in guilt.
  • The authors suggest workplaces that support the parent role of both mothers and fathers could ease mothers’ guilt.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2021; data collection year not found. A survey of 2,619 working parents in 110 organizations across 9 European countries.

Read the original paper →

British Journal of Social Psychology · 2023

When Work-Family Guilt Becomes a Women's Issue (Aarntzen et al., 2023)

Did you know? Mothers reported more work-family guilt than fathers, but only among parents with traditional unconscious gender stereotypes. Parents with egalitarian stereotypes showed no gender gap at all.

Key findings

  • Mothers reported more work-family guilt than fathers in the scenarios (a gap of 0.42 points on the guilt scale).
  • Among parents with egalitarian unconscious stereotypes, there was no gender gap in guilt. Among parents with traditional stereotypes, mothers felt much more guilty than fathers (a gap of 0.88 points, about double the overall gap).
  • Fathers with stronger traditional stereotypes felt less guilty. Mothers’ stereotypes did not change how guilty they felt in the scenarios.
  • In the diary study, mothers with traditional stereotypes had more work-family conflict on 8-hour work days (0.63 points higher) and no difference on days off.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2023; data collection year not stated. Two studies. In the first, 251 working parents (135 mothers and 116 fathers; 54% women), recruited at a Dutch science museum, were surveyed. In the second, 105 mothers (98% married or living with a partner, working about 29 hours a week) kept daily diaries.

Read the original paper →

Maternal & Child Nutrition · 2021

Guilt, Shame, and Postpartum Infant Feeding Outcomes: A Systematic Review

Did you know? One in three (33%) women who planned to breastfeed but exclusively formula fed felt guilty. Mothers who combined breast and formula feeding were about 6 times more likely to feel guilty than mothers who exclusively breastfed.

Key findings

  • 33% of exclusively formula-feeding women who had intended to breastfeed felt guilty.
  • Mothers who combined breast and formula feeding were about 6 times more likely to feel guilty than mothers who exclusively breastfed.
  • In one study of formula-feeding mothers, 30% felt guilt that came from within, 12% felt guilt tied to others, and 55% felt both. 68% reported guilt related to other mothers.
  • In a study of breastfeeding women, 59% felt guilt tied to family, 32% tied to other mothers, and 38% felt guilt that came from within.
  • Formula feeders’ guilt was tied mostly to healthcare professionals, while breastfeeders’ guilt was tied to peers and family.
  • Only 2 of the 20 studies defined shame, and none measured it with numbers.

Scope and participants

Year: searches run December 2017 to March 2018 and repeated in February 2020; published 2021; the studies reviewed were published 1997 to 2017. A review of the research on mothers’ guilt and shame about feeding their babies. Of 467 studies screened, 20 articles (published 1997 to 2017) were included.

Read the original paper →

The Family Journal · 2026

Mothers' Emotion Regulation in Response to Guilt (Prikhidko et al., 2026)

Did you know? Mothers said guilt followed yelling, name-calling or spanking, and not having enough time or attention for their kids. To cope, they aimed to be a good enough mother instead of a perfect one.

Key findings

  • Guilt followed yelling, name-calling or spanking, and feeling they had not given their kids enough time or attention.
  • Mothers described four ways of coping with guilt: building an identity beyond their kids, aiming to be a good enough mother instead of a perfect one, avoiding social comparison (especially on social media), and leaning on social support.
  • Social media could help or hurt, depending on the mother’s mood at the time.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2026; data collection year not stated. This is a qualitative study, so it reports themes and no percentages. In-depth interviews (35 to 50 minutes each) with 11 U.S. mothers (ages 38 to 61, with children from 12 months to 36 years old). Seven were married and four were single; 7 were White, 2 Asian American, 1 multiethnic and 1 Jewish, and 6 described themselves as religious.

Read the original paper →

Qualitative Sociology · 2021

Is Maternal Guilt a Cross-National Experience? (Collins, 2021)

Did you know? Mothers in all four cities felt guilt, but only in Rome and Washington, DC did mothers feel guilty for working at all. In Stockholm and Berlin, having a job did not itself trigger guilt.

Key findings

  • Guilt shaped what it means to be a good mother in all four countries.
  • In Stockholm and Berlin, being employed did not itself spur guilt. In Rome and Washington, DC, mothers felt guilty for working.
  • Leave policy showed up in the stories. One Stockholm mother’s partner took 8 months of leave, while a DC mother took about 4 months and her husband took 2 weeks. The U.S. is the only industrialized country without federal paid parental leave.
  • Context the author gives: 55% of Italian mothers are employed (35% full time, 20% part time), compared with 72% of U.S. mothers.
  • The author says policy can reduce guilt by giving mothers more time outside work, getting fathers to do more unpaid care, and spreading the costs of raising children more widely.

Scope and participants

Year: interviews 2013 to 2015 (Stockholm 2013, Rome 2014, Washington DC and Berlin 2015); published 2021. 109 interviews with working mothers: 25 in Stockholm, 27 in Rome, 32 in Washington DC and 25 in Berlin. Full-time employment in the sample was 81% in the U.S., 76% in Sweden, 63% in Italy and 43% in Germany. This is a qualitative study: it reports themes from four detailed cases, so there are no percentages by outcome. Of the 32 women in Washington, DC, 19 were white and 13 were women of color.

Read the original paper →

Journal of Family Psychology · 2025

Within-Person Changes in Parenting Guilt Predict Symptom Course in Mothers With Past or Current Depression (Milan & Xu, 2025)

Did you know? More than half of the mothers with a history of depression (54%) already scored above the depression cutoff, and a rise in guilt came before higher depression symptoms about 3.5 months later. Depression did not predict later guilt, so the pattern ran one way.

Key findings

  • 54% of mothers scored above the cutoff for depression at the start. Average guilt was 3.81 on a 5-point scale.
  • Mothers with more guilt overall also had more depression (a correlation of .42).
  • When an individual mother’s guilt rose, her depression symptoms were higher at the next check-in, about 1.7 points higher on the depression scale per 1-point rise in guilt. The reverse did not hold: depression did not predict later guilt.
  • The pattern was the same regardless of the child’s age or gender, and held when only mothers who completed every survey were counted.

Scope and participants

Year: data collected September 2020 to May 2021; published 2025. 225 U.S. mothers with a history of mood disorder (average age 37; 74% White and 13% Black; 62% married or living with the child’s father and 24% single), recruited online and surveyed at three points about 3.5 months apart. 84% completed the second survey and 72% the third.

Read the original paper →

4 studies

Parenting pressure and regret

The pressure to be a perfect parent, and what happens when real life falls short.

Behavioral Sciences · 2025

Maternal Regret and the Myth of the Good Mother (Iacona, Masina & Testoni, 2025)

Did you know? All 16 women who regretted motherhood described feeling pressured by patriarchal expectations, and almost all who tried to talk about their regret felt judged. They described guilt, inadequacy and anger that grew worse with an unequal load at home.

Key findings

  • All 16 women described patriarchal pressure around becoming a mother.
  • Almost all had tried to talk about their regret and felt judged for it.
  • Regret was tied to an idealized image of motherhood, social pressure, feeling trapped in a role, and a clash between their own identity and the perfect mother.
  • Women described guilt, inadequacy and anger that grew worse with an unequal household and childcare load, with fathers described as indifferent.
  • Context the authors cite: 55% of Italian women are employed vs. 69% across the EU, 1 in 5 leaves the labor market after having a child, and Italy gives 5 months of mandatory maternity leave to mothers vs. 10 days to fathers.

Scope and participants

Year: ethics approval May 2023, interview dates not stated; published 2025. This is a qualitative study, so it reports themes and no group percentages. Interviews with 16 Italian women who described themselves as regretting motherhood (ages 28 to 49, average 39; 6 lived abroad and 4 were not working; half held a university degree; none had more than two children). They were recruited through Facebook.

Read the original paper →

Sex Roles · 2025

Maternal Ambivalence and Mothers' Mental Health (Raneberg & MacCallum, 2025)

Did you know? 87% of UK mothers of young children rated themselves as falling short of an ideal mother. 23% scored above the cutoff for depression and 20% for anxiety, and shame and low self-compassion explained about 4 in 5 of the link between mixed feelings and those symptoms.

Key findings

  • 23% of mothers scored above the cutoff for depression and 20% for anxiety.
  • 87% rated themselves as falling short of an ideal mother, and a bigger gap made the effect worse.
  • Mothers who struggled more to manage mixed feelings about motherhood had more depression and anxiety. Shame and low self-compassion accounted for about 81% of the link with depression and 82% of the link with anxiety.
  • Mothers with more than one child had higher ambivalence scores (3.68 vs. 3.35).

Scope and participants

Year: data collected March 2024; published 2025. An online survey (via Prolific) of 499 mothers of children ages 0 to 5 in the United Kingdom (510 were recruited and 11 excluded; average age 33, with 2 children on average). Maternal ambivalence means holding positive and negative feelings about motherhood at the same time.

Read the original paper →

Frontiers in Psychology · 2018

Feeling Pressure to Be a Perfect Mother Relates to Parental Burnout and Career Ambitions (2018)

Did you know? Working mothers averaged 4.0 out of 7 on feeling pressure to be a perfect mother, and the more pressure they felt, the more burned out they were. Pressure pulled career ambition in two opposite directions.

Key findings

  • Mothers averaged 4.0 out of 7 on feeling pressure to be a perfect mother.
  • More pressure was linked to more burnout (a correlation of .34) and more parental stress (.49). The link to burnout ran partly through stress, a focus on avoiding mistakes, and maternal gatekeeping (not letting partners take over care). Together, the factors in the study explained 44% of the differences in burnout.
  • Pressure had two opposite links to career ambition: a small direct link to higher ambition, and an indirect link to lower ambition through worse work-family balance.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2018; data collection year not stated. A survey of 169 full-time working mothers (88% in the UK and 12% in the U.S.), recruited through Prolific. Average age was 37, they worked about 39 hours a week, and 85% were in a relationship. 186 were recruited and 17 were excluded.

Read the original paper →

Humanities & Social Sciences Communications · 2025

Unmasking the Notion of 'Supermom' in India (2025)

Did you know? Mothers in India were almost evenly split on the supermom idea: 154 of 305 (51%) saw it as beneficial and 151 (49%) saw it as harmful or a trap.

Key findings

  • Mothers were almost evenly split: 154 of 305 (51%) saw the supermom idea as beneficial and 151 (49%) saw it as harmful or a trap.

Scope and participants

Year: data collected May 2024; published 2025. Written responses from 305 earning mothers in India (80% employed full time, 90% in the private sector, 94% married; about half held a postgraduate degree; they worked 43 hours a week on average; 57% had two children and 42% had one) about what being a supermom means.

Read the original paper →

17 studies

Mental load, housework and time use

Who does the thinking, planning and unpaid work that keeps a household running.

Frontiers in Sociology · 2026

Understanding the Dimensions of Mental Labor: The Invisible Load of Italian Mothers (2026)

Did you know? Italian mothers rated the thinking and planning side of the load as their heaviest burden (4.3 out of 5), above managing the household (4.0) and emotional labor (3.2).

Key findings

  • The thinking and planning side of the load was the heaviest part (4.3 out of 5, vs. 4.0 for managing the household and 3.2 for emotional labor).
  • Traditional gender role attitudes and employment status predicted how heavy the load was. A partner’s work hours and how much practical help he gave were linked to how unequal it felt.
  • 72% of mothers got help from their partner, 26% from grandparents or friends, and 3% had no help.

Scope and participants

Year: survey fielded autumn 2024; published 2025 to 2026. A survey of 2,309 Italian mothers, ages 20 to 45, who each had one child (63% held a college degree). Only mothers were surveyed.

Read the original paper →

American Sociological Review · 2019

The Cognitive Dimension of Household Labor (Daminger, 2019)

Did you know? In 26 of 32 couples, the woman carried the heavier share of the thinking work behind running a household. On average women led 4.6 of 9 household areas, men led 1.6, and 2.2 were shared. Making the actual decisions was shared in 28 couples.

Key findings

  • In 26 of 32 couples, the woman carried the heavier cognitive load. On average women led 4.6 of 9 household areas, men led 1.6, and 2.2 were shared.
  • In 26 couples, the woman was the one who anticipated needs.
  • Women led the thinking work for childcare in 23 of 32 couples, for cleaning in 19, and for logistics and scheduling in 24. Men led the thinking work for finances in 14 couples.
  • Making the actual decisions was shared in 28 couples.

Scope and participants

Year: interviews June to December 2017; published 2019. 70 interviews with 35 Boston-area couples about who does the thinking work behind running a household (92% of the women and 70% of the men held advanced degrees). The counts above use the 32 different-sex couples.

Read the original paper →

American Sociological Review · 2020

De-gendered Processes, Gendered Outcomes (Daminger, 2020)

Did you know? No couple reported a 50/50 split on both physical and cognitive labor. 22 men and 23 women (out of 32 each) said the woman does more overall, and equal-partner couples explained the gap with gender-neutral reasons.

Key findings

  • No couple reported an even split on both physical and cognitive labor.
  • 22 of 32 men and 23 of 32 women said the woman does more overall.
  • 27 of 32 couples agreed on who did more, and 28 of 32 described little or only mild disagreement. Some couples described gaps of 90% or more.
  • Couples who saw themselves as equal partners still ended up with an unequal split, and explained it with gender-neutral reasons like who had more time or skill.

Scope and participants

Year: interviews June to December 2017; published 2020. 64 interviews with 32 different-sex, college-educated Boston-area couples (91% of the women and 69% of the men held advanced degrees; in 22% of couples the wife earned $5,000 or more above her husband). Average age was 35 for women and 36 for men; couples had 1.5 children on average and had been married about 6.6 years.

Read the original paper →

Journal of Marriage and Family · 2024

A Typology of US Parents' Mental Loads (Weeks & Ruppanner)

Did you know? Mothers said they do 79% of the daily thinking tasks, while fathers said they do 37%. Fathers claimed more of the occasional tasks like car servicing and finances (65% vs. 53% for mothers).

Key findings

  • Mothers held most of the core daily tasks tied to family well-being. Fathers held occasional tasks like home maintenance and finances. Mothers reported doing 79% of the daily tasks vs. 37% reported by fathers. Fathers reported doing 65% of the occasional tasks vs. 53% reported by mothers. Mothers most often said they alone handle cleaning out outgrown kids’ clothes (85%), the family calendar (83%) and researching what kids need (80%). Fathers most often said they alone handle car and boiler servicing (69%) and researching financial products (66%).
  • How a question was worded changed who got credit for the work.

Scope and participants

Year: survey fielded February to March 2023; published 2024 online, 2025 in print. A survey of 3,000 U.S. parents (matched to U.S. parents by age, race, gender and education) about 21 thinking and planning tasks.

Read the original paper →

Socius · 2025

Take a Load Off? Not for Mothers (Weeks et al.)

Did you know? Mothers earning $100,000 or more did 30% less childcare and 17% less housework, but their mental load did not shrink at all.

Key findings

  • When mothers earned more or worked more, they did less physical housework, but their mental burden did not shrink. Mothers reported primary responsibility for 68% more of the cognitive load than fathers. Employed mothers spent 17% less time on caregiving and 22% less on other housework. Mothers earning $100,000 or more did 30% less childcare and 17% less housework, but their cognitive load stayed the same.

Scope and participants

Year: survey fielded February to March 2023; published 2025. A survey of 2,133 partnered heterosexual U.S. parents.

Read the original paper →

2023

Managing a Household During a Pandemic: Cognitive Labor and Parents' Psychological Well-being (2023)

Did you know? In mothers’ reports, mothers spent 5.2 hours a week on household thinking and planning and fathers spent 1.7. In fathers’ reports, the gap nearly disappeared (3.7 hours for fathers and 3.9 for mothers).

Key findings

  • In mothers’ reports, mothers did 5.19 hours a week of cognitive labor and fathers did 1.66. In fathers’ reports, fathers did 3.65 hours and mothers 3.87.
  • Mothers scored higher than fathers on stress (2.74 vs. 2.47 on a 5-point scale) and depressive symptoms (1.95 vs. 1.73 on a 4-point scale).
  • More cognitive labor, and a bigger share of it, was linked to higher stress and depression for mothers, especially mothers who never worked from home or always did.
  • Mothers’ well-being was higher when fathers did more, especially for mothers who worked outside the home. Fathers’ time was unrelated to their own well-being, and a bigger share for fathers was linked to lower stress.
  • How physical household labor was split was unrelated to well-being.

Scope and participants

Year: surveys in April 2020, November 2020 and October 2021; published 2023. A survey of U.S. parents during the COVID-19 pandemic (1,000 mothers and 765 fathers in the main analysis, drawn from 1,966 parents).

Read the original paper →

Frontiers in Psychology · 2023

'It Was Too Much for Me': Mental Load, Mothers, and Working From Home During COVID-19 (2023)

Did you know? When schools, creches and grandparents were unavailable during COVID-19, childcare fell to mothers, and several described being on call around the clock. Flexible hours were what helped most.

Key findings

  • Working from home blurred the lines between paid work, care and housework, which added to mothers’ load.
  • Closures of schools, creches and grandparent care pushed childcare onto mothers.
  • Several mothers described being available around the clock.
  • Flexible working hours helped.

Scope and participants

Year: interviews in August 2021 and February 2022; published 2023. This is a qualitative study, so it reports themes and no percentages. 12 working mothers’ narratives, selected from 424 collected in two rounds, across 11 European countries (4 were single mothers and 8 had male partners; 7 were in their 40s).

Read the original paper →

Archives of Women’s Mental Health · 2024

Cognitive Household Labor: Gender Disparities and Maternal Mental Health (2024)

Did you know? Mothers said they did 73% of the planning but 64% of the doing, and did more of the planning on 29 of 30 tasks. The planning share was tied to depression, stress and burnout, while the doing share was tied only to relationship quality.

Key findings

  • Mothers said they did 73% of the planning but 64% of the doing, and did more of the planning on 29 of 30 tasks.
  • A bigger share of the thinking work was linked to more depression, stress and burnout. A lopsided split of the doing was linked only to lower relationship quality.

Scope and participants

Year: data collected May 30 to July 31, 2023; published 2024. 322 mothers of 3-year-olds (81% White, 33% with household income over $150,000) rated who handles 30 household tasks, separating planning from doing.

Read the original paper →

Sex Roles · 2019

Invisible Household Labor and Ramifications for Adjustment: Mothers as Captains of Households (Ciciolla & Luthar, 2019)

Did you know? Between 70% and 88% of mothers said they alone were responsible for household routines. Money decisions were mostly shared: 53% to 80% of mothers said they split them equally.

Key findings

  • Between 70% and 88% of mothers said they alone were responsible for household routines such as organizing schedules and keeping order. 64% said they alone watched their children’s emotions and 78% said they alone knew the teachers. Instilling values was shared equally by 72%, and 53% to 80% shared major money decisions equally.
  • More lopsided responsibility was linked to lower well-being and lower relationship satisfaction.

Scope and participants

Year: data collected 2005 to 2010; published 2019. 393 married or partnered U.S. mothers with children under 18 (about half had a graduate degree), drawn from an online survey of 2,247 mothers.

Read the original paper →

Community, Work & Family · 2021

The Mental Load: Building a Deeper Theoretical Understanding (2021)

Did you know? Mental load is more than a to-do list. It combines thinking work and emotional work that is invisible, hard to switch off and long-lasting.

Key findings

  • Defines mental load as a combination of thinking work and emotional work that is invisible, hard to switch off, and long-lasting.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2021. A theory paper rather than a data study.

Read the original paper →

Sex Roles · 2023

Gendered Mental Labor: A Systematic Literature Review

Did you know? In one study this review covers, 23% of women said they made most parenting decisions, compared with 2% of men. Women did a larger share of mental labor overall.

Key findings

  • Women did a larger share of the mental labor, especially decisions about childcare. In one included study, 23% of women vs. 2% of men said they made most parenting decisions.
  • It was linked to more stress, lower life and relationship satisfaction, and effects on careers.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2023; searches run November 2021 and May 2022. A review of 31 articles (20 from the U.S. and 8 from Europe) and mostly about middle-class families.

Read the original paper →

Work, Employment and Society · 2022

Gendered Housework: Spousal Relative Income, Parenthood and Traditional Gender Identity Norms (Syrda)

Did you know? Among married parents, the housework gap between mothers and fathers got wider as the wife’s share of income grew. In couples with children, the gap was about 4 hours a week wider.

Key findings

  • For childless couples, the housework split did not depend on who earned more.
  • Among married parents, the housework gap between mothers and fathers got wider as the wife’s share of income grew. This did not show up for unmarried couples. In couples with children, the wife-husband housework gap was about 4 hours a week wider.

Scope and participants

Year: data from 1999 to 2017; published 2022 online, 2023 in print. 6,643 U.S. dual-earner heterosexual couples followed from 1999 to 2017 (19,602 couple-years of data).

Read the original paper →

Psychology of Women Quarterly · 2025

Gender, Power, and Parenthood: Women Partnered With Women vs. Men

Did you know? On a scale from -10 to +10 where higher means she does more, mothers partnered with men scored 4.67 for household labor, compared with 1.88 for mothers partnered with women. Having a say in decisions predicted satisfaction in every group except mothers partnered with men.

Key findings

  • On a household labor scale from -10 to +10 (higher means she does more), mothers partnered with men scored 4.67, mothers partnered with women scored 1.88, and women without children partnered with men scored 1.98.
  • Across all women, those with male partners scored 3.65 and those with female partners 1.74.
  • For mothers, doing a bigger share of the labor was linked to lower satisfaction with the relationship.
  • Having a say in decisions predicted satisfaction in every group except mothers partnered with men.
  • Among women without children, being partnered with a woman predicted higher satisfaction.

Scope and participants

Year: data collected May to June 2023; published 2025 online, 2026 in print. 227 women recruited online through Prolific (102 partnered with women and 125 partnered with men; 53% were parents). 230 were surveyed, and relationships averaged about 12 years.

Read the original paper →

American Sociological Review · 2011

Revisiting the Gender Gap in Time-Use Patterns: Multitasking and Well-Being (Offer & Schneider, 2011)

Did you know? Mothers multitasked about 10 more hours a week than fathers (48.3 vs. 38.9). For mothers it was tied to more stress and work-family conflict, but fathers’ multitasking at home did not have those effects.

Key findings

  • Mothers multitasked 48.3 hours a week vs. 38.9 for fathers (about 24% more). Housework made up 52.7% of mothers’ multitasking at home vs. 42.2% for fathers, and childcare 35.5% vs. 27.9%.
  • For mothers, that was linked to more negative emotions, stress, distress and work-family conflict. Fathers’ multitasking at home did not have those effects.

Scope and participants

Year: data collected 1999 to 2000; published 2011. The 500 Family Study of 368 mothers and 241 fathers in middle-class dual-earner families in eight U.S. communities, using surveys and check-ins during the day.

Read the original paper →

PLOS ONE · 2022

Gender Differences in Time Use Across Age Groups: Ten Industrialized Countries 2005-2015 (Garcia Roman & Gracia, 2022)

Did you know? Italian women averaged 226 minutes a day on housework. In South Korea, men averaged 31 minutes a day on housework vs. 155 for women. Gaps were smallest for sleep and personal care.

Key findings

  • Gender gaps were smallest for sleep and personal care, then leisure, and largest for housework, caregiving and paid work.
  • Gaps were largest in South Korea, Hungary, Italy and Spain, and smallest in Finland, Canada, the U.S. and the UK. Italian women averaged 226 minutes a day on housework, while South Korean men averaged 31 minutes vs. 155 for South Korean women.
  • Housework and care gaps grew from adolescence to ages 30 to 44 and narrowed after 65.

Scope and participants

Year: data from 2005 to 2015; published 2022. Time diaries from ten countries, covering 201,972 people.

Read the original paper →

Community, Work & Family · 2020

Gender Differences in the Quality of Leisure: A Cross-National Comparison (Yerkes, Roeters & Baxter, 2020)

Did you know? Women felt more rushed during their free time than men (2.93 vs. 2.70 on a 5-point scale) across 23 countries. Their ability to relax and recover was about the same on average, but women’s was lower in countries with conservative gender norms.

Key findings

  • Women reported feeling more rushed in their free time than men (2.93 vs. 2.70 on a 5-point scale). Country differences did not change this gap.
  • Using free time to relax and recover was nearly equal on average (3.59 for women vs. 3.62 for men).
  • The relax and recover gap was biggest in countries with conservative gender norms, little childcare coverage, limited paternity leave and less political power for women. In more egalitarian countries it was smaller and sometimes reversed. The authors note these effects were small.
  • Paternity leave raised women’s leisure quality more than men’s. More childcare coverage went with lower leisure quality overall, but a smaller or reversed gap.

Scope and participants

Year: data from 2007; published 2020. Data from the 2007 International Social Survey Programme: 29,700 people (16,433 women and 13,267 men) in 23 countries.

Read the original paper →

Report · Not peer reviewed · 2023

In a Growing Share of U.S. Marriages, Husbands and Wives Earn About the Same (Pew Research Center, 2023)

Did you know? In marriages where the wife was the main earner, wives still spent less time on leisure than husbands (21.1 vs. 29.9 hours a week) and more on housework and caregiving.

Key findings

  • Wives were the sole earners in 6% of marriages, up from 2% fifty years earlier.
  • In marriages with roughly equal earnings, husbands spent more time on paid work and leisure than wives did. Husbands averaged 44.2 hours a week of paid work vs. 41.1 for wives, and 25.2 hours of leisure vs. 21.6.
  • Wives who were the main earner spent more time on caregiving and housework, and less on leisure, than their husbands. Housework was 4.8 hours a week for wives vs. 2.8 for husbands, caregiving 6.4 vs. 5.0, and leisure 21.1 vs. 29.9.

Scope and participants

Year: earnings data from 2022, survey in January 2023; published 2023. Pew analysis of government earnings and time-use data, plus a survey of 5,152 U.S. adults (January 18 to 24, 2023).

Read the original paper →

11 studies

Work, self-silencing, rumination and decision-making

Putting your own needs aside, overthinking, and the emotional demands of work.

Psychology of Women Quarterly · 1992

The Silencing the Self Scale: Schemas of Intimacy Associated With Depression in Women (Jack & Dill, 1992)

Did you know? Women who put aside their own needs to keep a relationship going were more depressed, with a link of about .5 in all three groups of women. In a small group of college men, self-silencing scored just as high (86 vs. 78 for women students) but did not track depression (.15, not significant).

Key findings

  • The scale, which measures putting aside your own needs and voice to keep a relationship going, worked reliably in all three groups.
  • More self-silencing was linked to more depression in all three (correlations of .52, .50 and .51). Average scores were 78 for students, 82 for the mothers and 100 for shelter residents (scale of 31 to 155). In a small preliminary group of 46 college men, scores were similar (86) but did not track depression (.15, not significant).

Scope and participants

Year: published 1992; data collection year not stated. Three groups of women: 63 college students, 140 women in battered women’s shelters, and 270 mothers of 4-month-olds who used cocaine during pregnancy.

Read the original paper →

Sex Roles · 2025

Advancing the Next Generation of Research on Self-Silencing and Depression

Did you know? Of 29 studies that compared genders, none found women self-silencing more than men. 19 found men higher and 10 found no difference. Self-silencing was most likely in unequal environments.

Key findings

  • Of 29 studies that compared genders on self-silencing, none found higher scores in women, 19 found higher scores in men, and 10 found no difference.
  • 56 of the 126 studies tested the link between self-silencing and depression. The link was stronger in women in 2 of the 6 studies that compared genders, which the authors say needs replication.
  • Self-silencing was most likely in unequal environments, with traditional gender role beliefs, and in conflict-heavy or power-imbalanced relationships.

Scope and participants

Year: searches run December 2023; published 2025 to 2026. A narrative review of 126 studies using the Silencing the Self Scale over three decades. Samples were mostly White and heterosexual, and gender was measured as male or female only.

Read the original paper →

Pakistan Journal of Humanities & Social Sciences · 2025

Self-Silencing, Marital Adjustment, and Mental Health: Married Men and Women (Naeem & Ehsan, 2025)

Did you know? Self-silencing explained about 14% of women’s distress but only 4% of men’s. It was tied to worse marriage adjustment for women (-.23) and to nothing for men (.01).

Key findings

  • For women, more self-silencing was linked to worse marital adjustment (correlation of -.23) and more distress (.38, explaining about 14% of the differences in distress).
  • For men, there was no link to marital adjustment (.01) and a weaker link to distress (.19, explaining about 4%).

Scope and participants

Year: published 2025; data collection year not stated. 387 married people (193 men and 194 women), ages 20 to 65, from several cities in Pakistan.

Read the original paper →

Frontiers in Psychology · 2023

Thinking Twice: Gender Differences in Repetitive Negative Thinking Across the Adult Lifespan (Lilly et al., 2023)

Did you know? Among people who were 18 in 2010, women averaged 1.24 on a 0 to 4 rumination scale vs. 1.04 for men. From the mid-40s on, men’s levels were equal or slightly higher.

Key findings

  • Rumination, or dwelling on negative thoughts, peaked in young adulthood and declined with age.
  • Young women, especially in younger generations, ruminated more than men. Among people who were 18 in 2010, women averaged 1.24 on the 0 to 4 scale vs. 1.04 for men (about 19% higher, by my calculation from the paper’s estimates). From the mid-40s on, men’s levels were equal or slightly higher.

Scope and participants

Year: surveys from 2010 to 2021; published 2023. 64,901 New Zealand adults ages 18 to 81 (40,793 women and 24,108 men), followed across 12 yearly surveys.

Read the original paper →

Archives of Women’s Mental Health · 2025

Gender Difference in Rumination Subtypes Connecting to Depression (Zou et al., 2025)

Did you know? For women, brooding (passively dwelling on problems) was the main link between rumination and depression. For men, it was reflection, the more analytical kind of thinking.

Key findings

  • For women, brooding (passively dwelling on problems) was the main link between rumination and depression. For men, it was reflection (more analytical thinking).
  • Women scored higher on brooding (2.46 vs. 2.30).

Scope and participants

Year: data collected March 15 to April 15, 2024; published 2025. 798 Chinese university students (403 men and 395 women, average age 21.4).

Read the original paper →

Personality and Individual Differences · 2013

Gender Differences in Rumination: A Meta-Analysis (Johnson & Whisman, 2013)

Did you know? Across 59 studies and over 14,000 adults, women ruminated more than men, but the difference was small (an effect size of .24).

Key findings

  • Women scored higher than men on rumination, brooding and reflection, but the differences were small (effect sizes of .24, .19 and .17).

Scope and participants

Year: published 2013; combines earlier studies. A meta-analysis of 59 studies covering 14,321 adults.

Read the original paper →

Journal of Behavioral Decision Making · 2021

Gender Differences in Decision-Making and Stereotype Threat (Villanueva-Moya & Exposito, 2021)

Did you know? Women placed under stereotype threat scored 11.0 on a gambling task where higher is better. Women not under threat scored 37.9, and men under the same threat scored 26.2.

Key findings

  • Scores on the gambling task (higher is better): women under stereotype threat 11.03, men under threat 26.19, women not under threat 37.85.
  • The gap between threatened and non-threatened women was very large (an effect size of 1.13).
  • Women with a high fear of negative evaluation did worst.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2021; data collection year not stated. 105 Spanish undergraduates (58 women and 47 men, ages 18 to 37) who took a gambling decision task; 110 were recruited (62 women and 48 men).

Read the original paper →

Current Psychology · 2023

Are Gender Roles Associated With Well-Being Indicators? (Villanueva-Moya & Exposito, 2023)

Did you know? Family was the basis for 21% of women’s key life decisions vs. 9% of men’s, and women rated their decisions as harder (5.6 vs. 5.0 out of 7).

Key findings

  • Women scored higher on traditionally feminine traits, fear of negative evaluation and regret, and lower on well-being.
  • Women’s key life decisions were based on work and family. Men’s were mostly based on work. Family was the basis for 21% of women’s key decisions vs. 9% of men’s, and women rated decisions as harder (5.6 vs. 5.0 out of 7).

Scope and participants

Year: published 2023; data collection year not stated. 203 Spanish adults (116 women and 87 men, ages 20 to 65).

Read the original paper →

Frontiers in Psychology · 2020

Spanish Women Making Risky Decisions in the Social Domain (2020)

Did you know? Women reported more social risk-taking than men (5.63 vs. 5.29 out of 7) and higher traditional femininity (4.88 vs. 4.57). Among women, but not men, more femininity went with more fear of negative evaluation, which went with fewer social risks.

Key findings

  • Women reported more social risk-taking than men (5.63 vs. 5.29 out of 7) and scored higher on traditional femininity (4.88 vs. 4.57). Fear of negative evaluation was the same (3.02 vs. 2.99).
  • Within women, more femininity was linked to more fear of negative evaluation, and more fear was linked to less social risk-taking. These links did not appear in men.
  • Femininity and fear of negative evaluation together explained about 10% of the differences in social risk-taking.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2020; data collection year not stated. 417 Spanish participants (281 women and 136 men, ages 17 to 30).

Read the original paper →

Social Science & Medicine · 2026

Emotional Labor Demands, Stratification, and Mental Health Pathways in Europe (Antonakakis, 2026)

Did you know? Women faced higher emotional demands at work than men even within the same occupations (0.39 vs. 0.32), and had more sleep problems (2.16 vs. 1.94).

Key findings

  • Women faced higher emotional demands at work than men, even within the same occupations (0.39 vs. 0.32 on an emotional-demands index). Women also had slightly lower wellbeing (67.0 vs. 69.2) and more sleep problems (2.16 vs. 1.94), while work stress, job control and social support did not differ by gender. Men faced higher demands in manual roles such as plant operation and craft work.
  • Work stress was the main route from emotional demands to poorer mental health.
  • Support from colleagues and managers weakened the link.

Scope and participants

Year: data from 2015; published 2026. 43,850 workers in 35 countries from the 2015 European Working Conditions Survey.

Read the original paper →

Industry survey · Not peer reviewed · 2026

Women @ Work 2026: A Global Outlook (Deloitte, 2026)

Did you know? 43% of women surveyed wanted to leave their current employer. 80% believed flexible working hurts career progression, and 85% believed their workload would not be adjusted if they cut hours.

Key findings

  • 54% were happy in their current job with no plans to leave. 43% wanted to leave, and 20% were actively looking.
  • 49% had a flexible work arrangement, but 80% believed flexible working hurts career progression and 85% believed their workload would not be adjusted if they cut hours.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2026. A survey of 7,500 women in workplaces across 15 countries.

Read the original paper →

3 studies

Body image

Body dissatisfaction in midlife and how it connects to mood and eating.

Body Image · 2021

Body Dissatisfaction in Midlife Women: The Applicability of the Tripartite Influence Model (Hockey et al., 2021)

Did you know? Pressure from family was the strongest predictor of body dissatisfaction in women ages 40 to 55, stronger than pressure from the media.

Key findings

  • Family pressure directly predicted body dissatisfaction, the strongest single link in the model (.43). Media pressure had a direct link of .20, and peer pressure led to more appearance comparison (.29).
  • The model explained 31% of body dissatisfaction, 28% of binge-purge symptoms, 33% of distress and 14% of restrained eating.
  • Body dissatisfaction was linked to restrained eating and binge-purge symptoms, which were linked to more distress.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2021; data collection year not stated. An online survey of 206 women ages 40 to 55 (average 46.75), 67% Australian. 63% were married, 79% had children and 52% worked full time. Only women were studied.

Read the original paper →

Archives of Women’s Mental Health · 2014

Body Image Satisfaction and Depression in Midlife Women: The Study of Women's Health Across the Nation (Jackson et al., 2014)

Did you know? Midlife women who saw themselves as unattractive had nearly 8 times the odds of depressive symptoms (7.74), and the result was not explained by body mass index.

Key findings

  • Women dissatisfied with their bodies had about twice the odds of depressive symptoms (1.91 times).
  • Women who saw themselves as unattractive had nearly 8 times the odds (7.74).
  • There was no difference by race, and results were not explained by body mass index.

Scope and participants

Year: published 2014; data collection year not stated. 405 midlife women (60.5% White, 39.5% African American) from the Chicago site of a large U.S. women’s health study. 63 of them (15.6%) had clinically significant depressive symptoms.

Read the original paper →

Obesity Facts · 2016

Body Dissatisfaction in Individuals With Obesity Compared to Normal-Weight Individuals: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (2016)

Did you know? The body dissatisfaction gap between people with and without obesity was bigger for women (1.18 standard deviations) than for men (0.58).

Key findings

  • People with obesity were much more dissatisfied with their bodies. The gap was large: 0.89 standard deviations on questionnaires and 1.41 on silhouette scales.
  • The gap was bigger for women (1.18 standard deviations) than for men (0.58), and being female was linked to higher body dissatisfaction (statistically significant, p = .007).

Scope and participants

Year: published 2016; searches run through December 2015. A meta-analysis of 17 articles covering 13,508 adults.

Read the original paper →

Keep reading

Want to go deeper?

Reflections is where I write about what this looks like in real life. All Her Own is where I am building coaching and experiences for women.